Alternative Energy Job Gains in Ohio

Background

Estimates of the effect of alternative energy on jobs vary wildly (e.g. 1, 2) and are controversial. In general, advocates only consider jobs created and opponents only consider jobs lost. Advocates need to realize that alternative energy displaces existing jobs at power plants and coal mines. Opponents need to recognize that alternative energy creates jobs; someone has to insulate the buildings and install the solar panels.

Renewable Energy

Since Ohio has less than two percent renewable energy (3), job changes should be small. This is confirmed by Table 1, which shows that even the largest estimates are well below one percent of the 5.2 million work force (4). There is a marked difference between the two parts of the table – job gains are from surveys (‘experiment’) while job losses are from computer analysis of the state’s economy (‘theory’).  There are problems with both approaches. The definition of green jobs is controversial (7) making the gains uncertain. The problems with losses are worse. The first two entries under ‘Computer Analysis’ use costs comparisons that are ‘misleading’ according to the leading authority on the subject (8). Analysis leading to the largest loss under ‘Computer Analysis’ uses a statistical model which answers the question, “What is my worst-case scenario?”(9). The last entry in Table 1 would only be valid if an extremely unfavorable cost difference between wind and fossil fuels persisted for a long time.

Table 1. Renewable Energy Job Changes

Jobs

Years

Analyzed

 

Reference
Survey
19,000 (a) 2012 (5)
14,400 (b) 2014 (1)
Computer Analysis
(9,753) 2008-25 (6)
(3,590) 2018 (c) (2)
(29,366) 2015

(2)

(a) out of 31,000 alternative energy jobs

(b) Out of 71,000 alternative energy jobs

(c) Uses a 2013 prediction of 2018 costs

 

We can estimate direct job losses due to coal plant closings at about 100 per plant (10), making a small dent in the job figures in Table 1. Ohio would need to quadruple its wind output to put one coal plant out of production.

 

Energy Efficiency

Efficiency job estimate are limited to the same surveys as above. Unlike renewable energy, I am unaware of any estimates of job losses due to energy, except for individual plants (10).  Between 2008 and 2013 Ohio lost about 3000 MW of coal plants and gained about 1500 MW of natural gas plants (11). At about 500 MW per coal plant, the job losses amount to about 300 workers.

 

 

Table 2 Efficiency Job Changes

Jobs Years

Analyzed

 

Reference
Survey
12,000 (a) 2012 (5)
57,000 (b) 2014 (1)

(a) Out of 31,000 alternative energy jobs

(b) Out of 71,000 alternative energy jobs

 

Combined

According to an OSU computer analysis, the combination of renewable energy and efficiency produce 3,200 jobs between 2008 and 2012 (13).

 

Discussion

The majority of the data shows job gains, which is not surprising. Since wind and solar are more labor intensive than fossil fuels, many more jobs are created by renewable energy than are displaced. Subtracting jobs displaced from the surveys (1, 5) makes no material change.

Conversely, subtracting survey results from the computer analyses (2, 6) changes the picture significantly.  Even if the 29,000 job loss in Ref. (2) were correct, the total job loss is halved. Further, subtracting the gain in efficiency jobs from it, turns a loss into a large gain. The other computer analyses turn into gains, even if efficiency is ignored.

I conclude that alternative energy in Ohio has resulted in job gains in the tens of thousands. In a separate report I pointed out that green energy has created more jobs in Ohio than shale mining (14).

References

(1) Environmental Entrepreneurs; Clean Jobs Ohio, May 2015;

http://www.cleanjobsohio.org/

(2) Randy T Simmons, et al., Renewable Portfolio Standards: Ohio, Utah State University, April 2015 http://emsc.legislature.ohio.gov/testimony

(3) PUCO, How does Ohio generate electricity? http://www.puco.ohio.gov/puco/?LinkServID=07FEA955-9818-B02E-9006A6E6834F7BA6#sthash.9CsGs2qI.dpbs

(4) Bureau of Labor Statistics, May 2014 State Occupational Employment and Wage Estimates

Ohio, http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes_oh.htm

(5) State of Ohio, Ohio Alternative Energy Job Survey Analysis, February 2013

http://www.lwvohio.org/assets/attachments/file/ODSA%20job%20survey%20(1).pdf

(6) American Tradition Institute, The Cost and Economic Impact of Ohio’s Alternative Energy Portfolio Standard, April 2011 http://www.atinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/04/ATI_OH_RPS_study.pdf

(7) Why don’t some state officials want you to read this report on ‘green’ energy jobs?, Columbus Dispatch, November 17, 2014 http://www.dispatch.com/content/stories/business/2014/11/16/report-on-green-energy-jobs-was-put-on-ice-during-debate.html

(8) The exact quote is “Since projected utilization rates, the existing resource mix, and capacity values can all vary dramatically across regions where new generation capacity may be needed, the direct comparison of LCOE across technologies is often problematic and can be misleading as a method to assess the economic competitiveness of various generation alternatives.”  Energy Information Administration, Levelized Cost and Levelized Avoided Cost of New Generation Resources in the Annual Energy Outlook 2015 http://www.eia.gov/forecasts/aeo/electricity_generation.cfm

(9) David Harper, An Introduction To Value at Risk (VAR), Investopedia, December 28, 2015

http://www.investopedia.com/articles/04/092904.asp?no_header_alt=true

(10) First Energy closing 6 coal-fired power plants, Ohio.com, January 26, 2012 http://www.ohio.com/news/break-news/firstenergy-closing-6-coal-fired-power-plants-1.257090

(11) EIA, Existing Electric Power Plant Generating Capacity By Energy Source by Producer by State Back to 1990, http://www.eia.gov/state/search/#?1=102&2=216

(13) Anon., Economic Analysis of Ohio’s Renewable and Energy Efficiency Standards, November 18, 2013 http://www.ohiomfg.com/wp-content/uploads/2013-11-22_lb_energy_deeps_nov_13_final.pdf

(14) A. R. Rosenfield, Green Energy Has Created More Jobs In Ohio Than Shale, January 6, 2016 https://alanpeg.wordpress.com/2016/01/06/green-energy-has-created-more-jobs-in-ohio-than-shale-2/

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s